Free Speech Tracker

List of Incidents in Uttar Pradesh -> Attacks -> 2012
Urdu daily editor attacked, PCI to investigate
Ref:
Faizabad, Uttar Padesh

The office of Manzar Mehdi, an editor-publisher of 'Aap ki Taqat,' a daily which promotes communal harmony, was attacked and ransacked by unidentified persons, possibly in retaliation for his writings which are critical of the politics of communalism.

According to a statement from social activist and Magsaysay awardee, Sandeep Pandey, some people broke the lock of Masjid which also led to his office. The first floor office was completely ransacked, his laptop, camera, scanner, inverter and other such equipment which are key to his carrying out his journalism work were destroyed. Overall, he has suffered a loss of about Rs. 2-3 lakhs.

The daily, in which the left page is in Hindi and the right one in Urdu with the slogan 'Hindu Muslim are two brothers and Hindi Urdu are two sisters, played a major role in promoting harmony.

Manzar Mehdi is the President of Urdu Press Association and attracts 80% of advertisements for his newspaper from establishments run by Hindus. He also runs a 'Guldasta Society' which organises a human chain every 26th January for promoting communal harmony. Hence, targetting him also means that saner voices will be silenced.

In response to a complaint, the Press Council has decided to investigate the attack.

The following is a press statement from the Press Council Chairman, Justice Markandey Katju

I have received a letter from Ms. Teesta Setalvad, Co-editor of Communalism Combat mentioning in detail a serious communal accident which occurred on the evening of October 24, 2012. According to this letter, a huge group of people attacked the Nawab Hasan Raja Masjid in the chowk area of Faizabad for four to five hours committing arson and looting including looting of a large number of shops. The aforesaid Masjid was totally gutted and destroyed by the vandals as also the office of the bilingual Hindi-Urdu publication "˜Aap ki Taaqat"™ that stands for communal amity and promotes the Ganga-Jumna Tehzeeb, and the concept "˜Hindi Urdu do Behen"™. The office of the aforesaid newspaper is in the first floor of the aforesaid Masjid. The editor of the publication, Manzar Mehdi, is President of the Urdu Press Association and the publication attracts 80 per cent advertisement support from the Hindu community. The Masjid every year welcomes the Durga goddess processionists and other processions with floral tributes. The mosque that dates back to 1790 A.D. has always practised and preached communal harmony.
What has hurt Mr. Mehdi most is the ambivalence of the national media (except the Hindustan daily which published the true facts) and he has alleged that the media has not seen it as an attack on the freedom of the press."Why is the media deserting its own, especially a small publication that has become a symbol of intercommunity harmony?" asked Mr. Mehdi.
It is alleged in the letter that the lock of the Masjid was broken, and the Masjid looted and gutted down. The newspaper Aap Ki Taaqat"™s office located on the top floor of the Masjid was also not spared, and it has been vandalized. Books were trampled upon and torn, the computer was destroyed.
On receipt of the aforesaid letter from Ms. Teesta Setalvad, I have today appointed a one man committee of Mr. Sheetla Singh, Member of the Press Council of India and a very senior journalist who is also editor of Jan Morcha of Faizabad to enquire into this complaint and submit his report at the earliest. I have spoken to Mr. Sheetla Singh and Ms. Teesta Setalvad on telephone.
If the allegations in the letter of Ms. Setalvad are correct it is a serious criminal offence which tends to disrupt the secular framework of our Constitution and society, and deserves condemnation and harsh punishment.