BANGLADESH MEDIA QUESTIONS GENERALS TRANSFER ON EVE OF TALKS WITH INDIA

IN Media Practice | 09/06/2002

 

 

http://www.tehelka.com/currentaffairs/july2001/ca070401indo1.htm


BANGLADESH MEDIA QUESTIONS GENERALS TRANSFER ON EVE OF TALKS WITH INDIA


Major General Fazlur Rahman has been transferred along with two of his colleagues for his alleged involvement in the April border clashes between India and Bangladesh, a move that is being fiercely contested in Bangladesh, says SALEEM SAMAD

Dhaka, July 4 the Bangladesh Rifles (BDR) top brass have been transferred just a few days ahead of the Indo-Bangla border talks. Liberation War veteran Major General Fazlur Rahman, Director General of BDR, border police, Brigadier Salam Chowdhury, Deputy Director General and Colonel Rafiqur Rahman, Director (Operation) were transferred to military jobs.

General Fazlur Rahman courted controversy after his "adventurism" in Padua (Bangladeshi for Pyrdiwah), a frontier village bordering the hilly state of eghalaya, which the BDR chief claimed has been used as a strategic base for the "Mukti Fauj" in 1971 Bangladesh War of independence against Pakistan. In April, the worst border skirmish in 30 years left several dead on both sides.

Bangladesh claims Indian troops had intruded into Bangladeshi territory, a claim India rejected, saying the Border Security Force (BSF) patrol was well within their own territory. India accused the "hawkish and hot-headed" General Fazlur Rahman, who had kept the government totally in the dark, for ‘masterminding’ the operation. Questions are being asked as to what prompted Bangladesh to take on the BSF after waiting three decades to resolve the dispute.

An action like that leaves too many unanswered question, which are sqeculated upon, not always to the government’s advantage

The Indian media did not hesitate to state that because the Bangladesh military was a legacy of the Pakistan army, a possibility of Rahman being connected to the notorious Pakistan Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) could not be ruled out.

However, Bangladesh stood behind the "valiant freedom fighter" of the 1971 war. He has been transferred to Bogra cantonment, as General-Officer-Commanding, 11 Infantry Division. In a telephone conversation with this correspondent, Rahman said he was in the process of handing over the charge. He is expected to take up his new assignment in the middle of July.

Such a decision has taken Bangladesh by surprise, which most have termed "unprecedented". An action like that leaves too many unanswered questions, which are speculated upon, not always to the government’s advantage.

Daily Star, an independent newspaper remarked in its editorial on July 3, "We are intrigued by the abrasive manner in which the BDR chief and other three officers have been apparently eased off.

Indeed, General Rahman’s unceremonious exit raises more questions than answers…... At any rate, since Fazlur Rahman’s professionalism and inspiring leadership had infused the border guard organisation of 45,000 men with new life and vigour, all in 18 months, he should have deserved better," the newspaper, edited by Mahfuz Anam, stated.

The newspaper argued, "Furthermore, he has had good credentials as an armed force officer. He also carries with him the reputation of having written a book on war tactics, said to be a ‘must’ reading for military science students in Bangladesh. When a person of Fazlur Rahman’s leadership qualities is jettisoned along with his deputies without sound reasons .., it is likely to affect the morale of the troops and officers in the BDR."

Rahman served as BDR chief for 18 months before receiving his marching orders, whereas according to tradition, senior military officers are on deputation in BDR and remain in the command post for a period of three years.

Prompt pro-active responses from both India and Bangladesh resulted in delegations of both countries holding parleys to resolve the border demarcation. Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina set the ball rolling after she spoke to her Indian counterpart Atal Behari Vajpayee, expressed "regrets", and promised a "thorough" investigation into the torture meted out to BSF jawans and the mutilation of their bodies. She insists that Bangladeshi border guards had opened fire in "self-defence".

Hasina’s assurance came hours after Delhi declared that the "Bangladesh government was unaware of the unilateral action on the part of the BDR. India has blamed the clashes on the BDR’s "criminal adventurism", saying its units had operated independently of the Bangladesh government.

Meanwhile, the official Indo-Bangla talks, which lasted three days, concluded on Wednesday. The second round of talks is slated to follow-up the meeting of the Joint Boundary Working Group (JBWG), a body of officials of the two countries, held in New Delhi in June after the April clashes left 17 BSF and three BDR jawans killed and 100 injured.

India has blamed the clashes on the
BDR’s "criminal adventurism", saying its
units had operated independently of the
Bangladesh government


Mohsin Ali, Additional Secretary, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, told tehelka.com on Tuesday that the three-day talks have discussed setting up a modus operandi for exchanging enclaves and lands in adverse possession by implementing the 1974 Indria-Mujib border agreement. The talks will also deal with the demarcation of disputed border areas between India and Bangladesh, he said.

In response to another question, he said they have raised the matter of the recent killings of Bangladeshi people by the BSF. Odhikar, a NGO, claims that at least 51 Bangladeshis were killed and another 300 injured in BSFfiring during the last six months.

According to the terms of reference of the JBWG, other outstanding border disputes centring around intrusion and firing by border guards will not come under the purview of the talks; neither will outstanding issues related to maritime border, trespassing and construction of barbed wire fencing by the Indian side be addressed.

A 14-member Indian delegation led by Meera Shanker, joint secretary of the Indian Ministry of External Affairs (MEA), arrived in Dhaka on Sunday to hold talks with the Bangladesh team led by Janibul Haq, Joint Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs.

There are 4427.58 km long borders between India and Bangladesh. But 6.5 kilometres still remains disputed. These span two kilometres at Muhurir Char in Tripura, two kilometres at Lathi Kila in Assam and 1.5 kilometres at Daikhata in West Bengal.

Besides, 35 kilometres of the demarcated border between India and Bangladesh remain sans border pillars at Berubari, Shingpara and Phudipara. Fifty-one enclaves covering 7,000 acres of Bangladesh are lying with India and 111 enclaves covering 17,000 acres of Indian land are lying with Bangladesh.

However, the series of tensions along the border demonstrates its fragility. evertheless, the skirmishes have prompted Delhi and Dhaka to settle the border problem once for all.