"The Kantipur
incident seems to be an aberration, the result of unusual times when judgements of those in power go awry.
Certainly, the mainstream
press does not feel the heavy hand of
government otherwise" says the much-interviewed editor of Himal,
Kanak Mani Dixit, from Kathmandu.
"The Press In Nepal Is Not
Otherwise Muzzled"
The
massacre of the Nepalese royal family has resulted in considerable focus
on the media in Nepal. The Hoot talked to
Kanak Mani Dixit, the editor of Himal, the South Asian magazine, and the
most frequently interviewed Nepalese journalist through the last fortnight’s
crisis, for his take on coverage by the local, Indian and Western media in his country. The interview was
conducted via email by Sevanti Ninan.
Why have the editors of Kantipur been arrested when the government has
not taken cognisance of numerous
local news sheets that have been allegedly publishing scurrilous or
dubious stories?
It is true, Nepal¿s
mainstream press has been providing ready space for the Maoist leadership to
place its opinion before the public.
The editor of Kantipur and two of its co-publishers were taken in for printing an article by the
Maoist ideologue Baburam
Bhattarai. The government of Prime
Minister Girija Prasad Koirala claims
that it has taken this action because of the extremely sensitive and unstable
moment in national life during which it was
printed. Bhattarai¿s article, carried on the editorial page as an opinion, calls the recent Royal Palace
murders the handiwork of Indian and
American intelligence, calls the new King Gyanendra an Indian stooge, and asks the officers and jawans
of the Royal Nepal
Army to revolt.Clearly, it was foolish
for the government to jail the editor and
publishers. Newspapers and their
editors are best left to self-regulate, and the fact that the government had
allowed pieces by Maoists to be printed earlier goes against its case.
Meanwhile,
editor Ghimire himself had written an
editorial severely criticising the piece by the Maoist leader in the paper the
following day.I would only like to add one note of caution to foreign friends
who
are concerned about press freedom in
Nepal: this incident seems to be an aberration and the result of unusual times
when judgements of those in power go awry. Certainly, the mainstream
press does not feel the heavy hand of
government otherwise, and the press is not otherwise muzzled.
2) Broadly, how would you classify the local media in Nepal, and
what role does each of these categories play?
Given Nepal¿s non-colonised status, Nepali language papers are overwhelmingly important in Nepal, and not the English press. The daily broadsheets have expanded reach dramatically in the last decade of press freedom, putting the party-affiliated weekly tabloids in a bit of shade.